“It’s important that we not promote carbon dioxide removal as a replacement for emissions reduction,” said Michael Leitch, the technical lead for the competition. “But the race is really on both to dramatically reduce our existing emissions (and) also … deploy carbon dioxide removal solutions at very, very large scales globally.” The prize is being awarded at a time when Musk and his Department of Government Efficiency are making steep cuts to federal funding and staff at the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, the National Weather Service and other science-based agencies that carry out important climate research. The Trump administration has also moved to roll back myriad environmental regulations, including some that regulate carbon emissions.
While the Musk Foundation sponsored XPRIZE Carbon Removal, which distributed a total of $100 million, it is not formally affiliated with the California-based organization, XPRIZE officials said.
XPRIZE runs other contests to try to solve societal challenges. Executive director Nikki Batchelor said the organisation is considering more climate-related competitions addressing such issues as removal of the potent greenhouse gas methane, reforestation and climate adaptation and resilience.
Mati Carbon CEO Shantanu Agarwal believes his company’s relatively low-cost approach “has a potential to really solve some planetary scale problems” while helping small farmers who often bear the brunt of climate change, as extreme weather events like drought and floods destroy crops.
The method, called enhanced rock weathering, is fairly straightforward, said Jake Jordan, the company’s chief science officer: When it rains, water and carbon dioxide mix in the atmosphere, forming carbonic acid, which falls on rock and eventually breaks it down into small bits of silica. The carbonic acid is converted to a mineral called bicarbonate, which cannot re-gas to the atmosphere and eventually is washed to the ocean, where it is stored for about 10,000 years.
Mati Carbon spreads already-crushed basalt rock — plentiful in many parts of the world — on the fields “to speed up something that happens anyway,” Jordan said. The crushed rock also releases nutrients that help regenerate soils and increase productivity.
Smaller prizes were awarded in the competition’s final year to several other teams that also successfully removed 1,000 tons of carbon dioxide, a threshold that demonstrates an ability to scale up to remove gigatons in the coming decades.
That included $15 million to runner-up NetZero, which turns crop residues such as coffee husks into biochar, charcoal-like particles that can be used on fields to help store carbon in soils while also improving nutrient and water retention.
Other projects involved storing organic waste deep underground, enhancing oceans’ ability to store carbon and removing carbon directly from the air.
Scientists have been exploring the gamut of so-called geoengineering solutions to climate change, from drying the upper atmosphere to pumping minerals into the ocean to absorb carbon.
Rick Spinrad, former administrator at NOAA, called the finalists’ solutions “scientifically extraordinary concepts” and said the best approach to reducing carbon probably will be a combination of technologies.
Leitch, from XPRIZE, said some solutions that did not win — including direct air and direct ocean capture of carbon dioxide — might have an advantage when deployed on a large scale.
“It takes a lot of time and money to build, so I think time will tell,” Leitch said. (AP) ZH ZH ZH
